Dear Mike and Mr. Z-A.
I am following up on our discussion regarding entrance into 7th grade Algebra at ARMS. A number of other parents have concerns about this process and have contacted me about my discussions with you, and so with their permission I am including them in this note.
As a whole, I find the group of 6th grade parents who I know, are puzzled by the stance that Amherst Regional Middle School takes toward mathematics placement of seventh graders. I hope you will examine these concerns seriously and consider following the recommendations included at the close of this letter.
Mr. Z-A, you said in your e-mail to me:
“…we teach the great majority of 7th graders in a heterogeneous classroom setting. We differentiate our instruction with the goal that every student is appropriately challenged, is held to high standards, and progresses in their math learning. The more advanced material is offered to all of our students through our program called extensions.
“While this range of material and instruction is appropriate for most of our 7th graders, each year we find there are a very few (about 2-3%) who can demonstrate that they already have mastered the material that we cover in the 7th grade extension program. … So, while the great majority of our high level 7th graders are appropriately placed in the extension program, the few that are already beyond that point can participate in an Honors Algebra class, but it is an 8th grade class.
“We start with a general pre-test for all students during the first week of school. From certain problems on this pre-test we identify students that might be already experienced with the 7th grade extension material and we do ask them to take another test to determine if they might be one of the few each year who can move up to 8th grade Algebra.”
It seems that your placement of a small percentage of seventh graders into 8th grade honors algebra is done from a position of pedagogic passivity. If a student happens to have, for whatever reason, enough foundational math knowledge, he or she may take algebra as a 7th grader.
There is, however, no formal attempt made to prepare all, some or really any 6th graders for this exciting learning opportunity. Explicitly, pre-algebra is not offered as part of the districts’ 6th-grade math curricula; samples of the tests given to 7th graders in September are not given out to all 6th graders; 7th-grade math texts and syllabi are not offered and easily accessible to all incoming 7th graders during the summer after their 6th-grade year. Therefore, the only incoming 7th graders who are prepared to take and pass the pre-test and follow-up test are:
- those who are individually coached by the few 6th-grade teachers who choose to do so;
- those whose parents are aware of the opportunity to place out of 7thgrade math and have the resources to provide extra instruction for their children; and/or
- those few students with a very strong natural knack for math.
Surely, the middle school would like to, and has an obligation to, provide equal access and opportunity to all members of the community, and not only to these three small (and overlap makes them even smaller) subsets mentioned above. I believe that the middle school administration wants to be on record for not having tracking in math. Clearly there is an ad hoc tracking system, without labeling it as such. It is hard for me to see how, with a stated policy in place that does allow qualified 7th graders to take algebra, a school can in good conscience not make every effort to ensure that every potentially qualified 6th grader has a good-faith chance to prepare for and pass the two required tests given at the start of 7th grade.
Mr. Z-A, you offer the idea that students and parents can go to the ARMS website and view curriculum maps to find out what they need to know to be ready for algebra, i.e., whether they already know or can learn the material in 7th-grade extensions. While well intended, this suggestion is unrealistic. Anyone but a math teacher looking at the benchmarks for “Accelerated Standards” is going to find it virtually impossible to translate the purely narrative content into math problems that can test a child’s knowledge or teach him or her new material. (See the website at http://www.arps.org/Curriculum/Maps/MS/Mathematics/Grade7.pdf .) Directing interested parents and young students to this curriculum map is a convoluted, discouraging and a completely unnecessary step in what should be a straightforward, transparent process.
Recommendations for Making Honors Algebra accessible to all qualified and motivated 7th Graders:
- Communicate with 6th grade parents and students early in the year (and for this year, NOW) about the middle and high school math curricula, options within the curricula, and specifically, the opportunity to prepare for testing to qualify to take 8th grade honors algebra as a 7th grader.
- Samples of the pre-test and follow-up test should be distributed to all 6th graders in the districts. Since it is already almost May, this should also happen NOW. In future years, distribution should occur even earlier, so that motivated students have time to go over questions with their teachers.
- Seventh grade mathematics textbooks, as well as a syllabus with specific assignments given for the entirety of the seventh grade year, should be made available to ALL graduating 6th graders to take home for the summer before 7th grade. These books should be offered to the students by their 6th-grade teachers on or before the last day of school. I feel certain that parent volunteers from each of the elementary schools can be found to pick up the books at ARMS and deliver them to their respective schools before the close of the year if necessary. At the high school, students check out AP books in the last few days of school so that they can be working on the material over the summer before their course begins in the fall
I, along with these other 6th grade parents, look forward to hearing from you soon about this time-sensitive matter, and more importantly, seeing the implementation of these recommendations for open communication and preparation for the algebra placement test in 7th grade. Please ‘reply to all’ in your response. Thank you very much.